Skip to main content

New Media Flak: Megaphone vs. Cocktail Party

2 min read

Summary: A recent back and forth in the opinion pages of GW’s paper of note brought to light an emerging divide in publicists’ approaches to social media.

Heads up! This post is archived and here for historical purposes. It may no longer be accurate or reflect my views. Proceed at your own risk.

A recent back and forth in the opinion pages of GW’s paper of note brought to light an emerging divide in publicists’ approaches to social media. On the one hand, GW’s primary Twitter account, GWTweets, casts the University in a stoic, buttoned-up light, with little, if any interactions with members of the rather active online community (For example, mentions, @replies, or ReTweets). GWToday on the other hand, the de facto hub of the campus’s Twitter scene, and arguably a significant presence in higher education’s social media world, has historically taken a more cavalier approach to serving as the University’s digital face. But which approach is “best”?

Woman using a megaphone to yell at a man

Technology has the bad habit of upsetting social norms, and as much as we try, there’s nothing we can do to stop it.1 Organizations looking to establish a presence on Twitter cannot afford to treat social media like other media they may have encountered. Social media is not a megaphone for flaks to broadcast the press releases they would otherwise post elsewhere, but rather a cocktail party that gives organizations the chance to loosen their tie, grab a drink, and work the room.

A generation of communications directors and public affairs vice presidents sees the liberalizing power of social media as a liability, rather than an opportunity. Personal interaction with stakeholders, be they students at a university or just those who enjoy delicious, delicious sandwiches,2 allow organizations to connect with the people most passionate about their brand in a real way. Just as it is second nature for city dwellers to walk past solicitors handing out pamphlets on the street corner, as the culture surrounding the technology continues to evolve so too will Twitter community begin to ostracize those members who refuse to join the ongoing digital dialog.

Twitter is not a dumping ground for pre-vetted paper.3 The occasional typo or personal quip doesn’t hurt a company’s reputation, but rather humanizes it. As long as GWToday (or any corporate handle for that matter) falls short of sharing a picture of what they’re having for lunch, we can only hope that they continue to be the model for establishing an online presence, rather than the exception.

[Photo: tranchis]

Footnotes

Footnotes 3
  1. Without too much of a history lesson, see, for example, Abraham Lincoln overseeing the Civil War from the telegraph office ushering in a new era of hands-on presidential leadership; home telephones giving rise to entire industries dedicated to interrupting families’ dinners; Blackberrys changing business email etiquette. ↩︎

  2. Jimmy John’s often frat-boy-esque vocabulary may push the limits of informal interactions with stakeholders, but none-the-less serves to promote their brand. ↩︎

  3. Thank the internet gods that TwitterFeed’s RSS to Twitter conversion service didn’t catch on. ↩︎

Keep reading

Ben Balter

I'm Ben Balter, and I write here about developer platforms, product and engineering leadership, open source, and showing your work. I'm a principal product manager for API (developer) experience at Cloudflare, where I work on making it an even better place to build, for developers and their agents. Before that, I spent over a decade building developer platforms at GitHub. For five years I was a product manager for trust and safety, shipping 500+ features and policies to 50M+ developers, plus github.com API endpoints for trust and safety workflows. I also led a bottom-up rewrite of GitHub Pages, maintained Jekyll, and wrote the plugins most GitHub Pages sites run on. My open source projects have hundreds of millions of downloads. I wrote Open and Async, the playbook for remote and distributed teams. More about the author

Follow along: Bluesky LinkedIn

Originally published September 13, 2010 View revision history

This page is open source Help improve this article on GitHub

Keyboard shortcuts

Search

  • / or ⌘ K Open search
  • ↓ or j ↑ or k Move through results
  • Enter Open the selected result
  • Esc Close search

Go to

  • g then h Home
  • g then p All posts

This page

  • y Copy link to this page
  • ? Show this list

Turn off if you use voice control or keep triggering them by accident. ⌘ K still opens search, and this list stays under "Keyboard shortcuts" in the footer.